What motor to use for lathe spindle?
Posted: Tue Nov 13, 2018 10:47 pm
Hi guys
The spindle motor on the machine is a CTB brand china 2.2KW 3hp servo and has a driver in the cabinet.
I don't want to entertain the idea of trying to make it work with Acron. I want something I can get support for and/or do myself.
So this was the first part I pulled and plan on getting squared away first.
I have 2 options.
1: Is regular C face mount 3 phase motor and VFD. Lesson makes a 3,4 and 5.5 hp metric motors with a 28mm shaft that the pulley will fit.
The lathe motor mount plate will need to be modified for the Lesson motors to bolt up. No big deal.
Draw backs to this option. The CTB servo motor weighs 60lbs. Lessons range from 93-115lbs. And the lesson motors are to long to fit in the lathe without modified the coolant funnel and moving a brace under the stand.
Cost: 5.5hp motor $626.00 VFD $283.99 braking resistor $50.00 Centroid encoder cable $85.00 encoder $240.00. total cost $1284.99
Plus at least a day modding the stand to make room for the longer motor. Only need about an inch... lol And that's if the extra 40 plus lbs don't cause issues with belt tracking due to bracket flex. It's 3/4 mild steel BTW.
2: Is use a Clearpath Integrated Servo motor. Step and Direction. Can Acorn use this motor as a spindle motor and thread?
If run on 3 phase power they rate it at 4hp continuous and 7hp peak. If run on 220V single phase the power is a little less.
Draw backs to this option. RPM is limited to 2760. I don't think that is a big deal. I make parts on my manual lathe with a 2000 rpm limit and get by just fine. Weight 28.3 lbs. It's about 2" shorter than the CTB motor I took out so it would fit with no issues. The D100* frame size also has a 28mm shaft
so my pulley with work but like the Lesson motor the motor mount plate will need to be modified for the motor to bolt up.
Cost: Motor with cooling fan $1232.00 CPM-CABLE-M2P2P-120 $13.00 CPM-CABLE-CTRL-MU120 $23.00 RES-225 Regenerated Energy Shunt $152.00
Total cost $1420.00
https://www.teknic.com/model-info/CPM-S ... =230VAC3ph
The lathe is setup with Nema 42 AC servos. My plan is to replace them with DMM servos of the same size.
The spindle motor on the machine is a CTB brand china 2.2KW 3hp servo and has a driver in the cabinet.
I don't want to entertain the idea of trying to make it work with Acron. I want something I can get support for and/or do myself.
So this was the first part I pulled and plan on getting squared away first.
I have 2 options.
1: Is regular C face mount 3 phase motor and VFD. Lesson makes a 3,4 and 5.5 hp metric motors with a 28mm shaft that the pulley will fit.
The lathe motor mount plate will need to be modified for the Lesson motors to bolt up. No big deal.
Draw backs to this option. The CTB servo motor weighs 60lbs. Lessons range from 93-115lbs. And the lesson motors are to long to fit in the lathe without modified the coolant funnel and moving a brace under the stand.
Cost: 5.5hp motor $626.00 VFD $283.99 braking resistor $50.00 Centroid encoder cable $85.00 encoder $240.00. total cost $1284.99
Plus at least a day modding the stand to make room for the longer motor. Only need about an inch... lol And that's if the extra 40 plus lbs don't cause issues with belt tracking due to bracket flex. It's 3/4 mild steel BTW.
2: Is use a Clearpath Integrated Servo motor. Step and Direction. Can Acorn use this motor as a spindle motor and thread?
If run on 3 phase power they rate it at 4hp continuous and 7hp peak. If run on 220V single phase the power is a little less.
Draw backs to this option. RPM is limited to 2760. I don't think that is a big deal. I make parts on my manual lathe with a 2000 rpm limit and get by just fine. Weight 28.3 lbs. It's about 2" shorter than the CTB motor I took out so it would fit with no issues. The D100* frame size also has a 28mm shaft
so my pulley with work but like the Lesson motor the motor mount plate will need to be modified for the motor to bolt up.
Cost: Motor with cooling fan $1232.00 CPM-CABLE-M2P2P-120 $13.00 CPM-CABLE-CTRL-MU120 $23.00 RES-225 Regenerated Energy Shunt $152.00
Total cost $1420.00
https://www.teknic.com/model-info/CPM-S ... =230VAC3ph
The lathe is setup with Nema 42 AC servos. My plan is to replace them with DMM servos of the same size.