Bad Acorn controller <nope, resolved>
Posted: Sun Mar 09, 2025 4:39 pm
I think we have a bad Acorn controller. It was purchased about 2 years ago by the high school FIRST team for our FrankenRouter build. We just got it running for the first time in January of this this year and have not been able to make a single part for our robot as the Z axis has lost position, drifts upward. I am an automation engineer familiar with motion controls and proper wiring with respect to grounding, shielding keep power wires away from signal wiring etc. I also have my own homebuilt CNC that I recently converted from Mach 3 to an Acorn and it works flawlessly.
On the school machine I used the 24vdc drive connectors with 2K dropping resistors because I tend to stay away from 5vdc signals on industrial equipment. However I also made up a D25 connector for the Z axis at 5vdc and it misses steps there as well. We have 4 identical axis motors and 4 identical Leadshine drives. Moving the motors and the drives around the problem only occurs when using the Z output. X&Y work flawlessly and the X and Y axis outputs run the Z axis flawlessly too. So the only common with the problem is the Z axis output from the Acorn. I have also tested all the system voltages and the Acorn is powered by the power supply that came with it and it runs nothing else. That power is also fed from a voltage regulating UPS so power spikes from the spindle or axis drives are extremely unlikely.
So at this point the only part that hasn't been swapped/replaced is the Acorn itself. How do we proceed?
On the school machine I used the 24vdc drive connectors with 2K dropping resistors because I tend to stay away from 5vdc signals on industrial equipment. However I also made up a D25 connector for the Z axis at 5vdc and it misses steps there as well. We have 4 identical axis motors and 4 identical Leadshine drives. Moving the motors and the drives around the problem only occurs when using the Z output. X&Y work flawlessly and the X and Y axis outputs run the Z axis flawlessly too. So the only common with the problem is the Z axis output from the Acorn. I have also tested all the system voltages and the Acorn is powered by the power supply that came with it and it runs nothing else. That power is also fed from a voltage regulating UPS so power spikes from the spindle or axis drives are extremely unlikely.
So at this point the only part that hasn't been swapped/replaced is the Acorn itself. How do we proceed?